Tony Plath

Senior Vice President


Tony Plath

419-794.3960 office
419.290.2186 mobile
419.794.6064 fax

vCard Download Bio
Send a message

Professional Experience

Tony Plath is a veteran real estate professional in the Greater Toledo market with more than 25 years experience. He understands investment properties after being involved in the sale, management and ownership of thousands of multi-family units and other investment properties. In 2003, as President of the Apartment Council of the Home Builders Association of Greater Toledo (HBA), he was asked to become the Executive Officer of the entire association, a position he held for seven years. Mr. Plath received many accolades for improving services to members as well as recognition from the public and political communities for engaging the 600-plus member association in a higher level of ethical and professional standards. While enjoying the challenges of this position, he long felt the pull to come back to investment real estate brokerage. Upon retiring from the HBA, Tony became a team member of the Reichle Klein Group Investment Property Advisors, rejoining with a number of professionals with whom he had worked earlier in his career.

The Investment Property Advisors team specializes in private market real estate sales. The team's expertise is in understanding the capital markets, knowing and accessing private capital investors as well as underwriting and developing marketing strategies for investment properties. Their in-depth knowledge and ability to source private capital have served to create optimum value for their clients. They leverage web marketing technology and their proprietary national investor database to create a national market for Toledo area assets. In all, the Toledo Investment Property Advisors have participated in sales with a total consideration in excess of $376,000,000.

Following is a partial list of properties Tony has transacted:

Apartments Property Size Value
Looyd Portfolio 952 Units $31,500,000
Harris Portfolio 951 Units $23,000,000
ARCAP Portfolio 946 Units $15,000,000
Enclave II 144 Units $7,200,000
Arbor Glen Apartments 504 Units $6,800,000
Covington Greens Apartments 144 Units $6,600,000
Beacon Place 201 Units $6,325,000
North Towne Villas 146 Units $6,300,000
Green Meadow Apartments 190 Units $4,150,000
University Hills 156 Units $2,585,000
Hidden Village 72 Units $2,200,000
Tudor Arms 96 Units $1,790,000
Stanbery Homes Portfolio (Oak Ridge Dr.) 48 Units $1,550,000
Longwood Apartments 100 Units $1,400,000
Devonshire Apartments 87 Units $1,200,000
Park Lane Luxury Apartments 94 Units $1,100,000
LeParc 27 Units $800,000
O’Loughlin Portfolio 30 Units $783,600
Eagle Springs 29 Units $735,000
2905 Tremainsville Rd. 24 Units $575,000
Stateline Apartments 32 Units $480,000
Gatehouse 23 Units $460,000
Bayview Apartments 96 Units $429,000
Harbor House 21 Units $360,000
Swan Park 589 Units Undiclosed
Office Properties Property Size Value
MidFirst Bank Portgolio 129,786 SF $8,000,000
Liberty Square 31,970 SF $2,800,000
Industrial Properties Property Size Value
Magna Exteriors & Interiors of America, Inc. 177,500 SF $9,100,000
NES Rentals (Perrysburg, OH) 14,560 SF $1,250,000
1300 Flagship Dr. 24,000 SF $1,100,000
NES Rentals (Ft. Wayne, IN) 15,485 SF $900,000
Retail Properties Property Size Value
Timberstone Commons 56,321 SF $2,100,000
Library Plaza 34,475 SF $1,905,000
Byrning Hill Shopping Center 69,942 SF $700,000


Clients Represented

  • MidFirst Bank
  • Huntington Bank
  • Dermody Properties
  • James (Skip) Aston
  • West Valley Dev./ Craig Harris
  • Monroe Bank & Trust
  • Trimont Real Estate Advisors
  • Maumee Valley Properties / Joe Goodell & Gary VanCleef
  • TransCon Builders, Inc.
  • Stanbery Homes, Inc.
  • Hubbard & Hubbard Properties
  • First Eleven LLC
  • ET Properties Ltd.
  • J A Rental Properties, LLC
  • Ruth Ann O’Loughlin, Trustee

Property Finder

News & Information

Case Studies

114 S. Byrne Road, Toledo, Ohio

Byrning Hill Plaza

Challenge: Our team was hired thru the Receiver to sell this property on behalf of a Receiver appointed at the request of Huntington Bank. We listed the property at $1.4M and put together a thorough offering memorandum f…

380 Dussel Drive, Maumee, Ohio

Tolson Enterprises

Challenge: Tolson Enterprises was interested in selling an investment property that was approaching the end of the primary tenant’s term. The focus was to be on potential users or Investors. The challenge was to find an …

1800 Nathan Street, Toledo, Ohio

Magna Exteriors & Interiors of America Inc.

Challenge: We were engaged to sell a 177,500 SF single tenant, net leased, Class A industrial asset with a newly negotiated lease term of 8 and one half years.  Our first challenge was to obtain the listing as listing di…

1331 McCord Road, Holland, Ohio

Shops at Spring Meadows Place

Challenge: The developer/owner decided to put a newly constructed, multi-tenant strip center on the market. The pricing and cap rate were aggressive for the Toledo market, and 1,320 square feet of the center remained vac…

5415 Monroe Street, Toledo, Ohio

Huntington Bank / Nic Dumas, Duma Properties, LLC

Challenge: We were engaged as Receiver tasked with assuming the management and selling of a suburban multi-tenant office building. The major tenant in the building was the owner of the property who was not performing the…

3103 Executive Parkway, Toledo, Ohio

Medical Mutual of Ohio

Challenge: Leverage a hot investment property market in the disposition of a 100,000 square foot office tower in suburban Toledo.  The Client, Medical Mutual of Ohio, no longer occupied the building and had leased the en…

1311 McCord Road, Holland, Ohio

Sky Bank

Challenge: The developer/owner decided to put a newly constructed, build to suit, single-tenant property on the market subsequent to lease execution.  The pricing and cap rate were quite aggressive for the Toledo market …

1695, 1705 & 1715 Indian Wood Circle, Maumee, Ohio

John Barone

Challenge: The owners of Arrowhead Properties, two Class A multi-tenant office properties located in prestigious Arrowhead Business Park, decided the time was right to opportunistically attempt to take advantage of what …

1697, 1705 & 1715 Indian Wood Circle, Maumee, Ohio

Midfirst Bank

Challenge: We were asked to take this largely vacant REO office building portfolio to market for sale in the depths of the recession in 2010.  Office properties in tertiary markets were perhaps the least favored asset cl…

127 & 133 Mel Simon Drive, Toledo, Ohio

North Towne Villas

Challenge: We were engaged by the owner of North Towne Villas, a two member LLC that had originally developed the property, to sell the community in order to take advantage of the strong market for apartment investment p…